You’re about to embark on a journey through the world of soft-sided carry-on luggage, where eight top-rated options are put to the test. In a video by Away Together, you’ll find a comprehensive review of these carry-ons, featuring well-known brands like Swiss Gear, London Fog, and TUMI, among others. Each bag is evaluated on various criteria, including design, functionality, and value, while keeping in mind the standard carry-on size requirements.
In these reviews, you’ll discover which bags stand out for their style, durability, and unique features, such as four spinner wheels or telescoping handles. Find out why the Samsonite Ascentra and TravelPro Platinum Elite are top picks and see if the Swiss Gear option offers the best value for budget-minded travelers. With expert tips and additional travel resources included, you’re sure to find the perfect travel companion for any adventure.
This image is property of i.ytimg.com.
Overview of Soft Side Carry-On Luggage
Definition and Characteristics
When you think of soft side carry-on luggage, picture bags made from flexible materials such as fabric or nylon that offer a softer shell compared to their hard-sided counterparts. These bags are popular for their adaptability and ease of packing, as they can expand slightly to fit in those extra souvenirs. They often come with external pockets, making it simple to access your essentials without opening the main compartment. The flexibility ensures they fit snugly in overhead compartments, even if you’ve overstuffed them a little.
Comparison with Hard Side Luggage
Soft side luggage stands out compared to hard shell options due to its ability to flex and compress, giving you a bit more room for maneuvering in tight spaces. Hard side luggage, often made from polycarbonate or aluminum, is prized for its durability and ability to protect fragile items. But, when it comes to fitting in small spaces or squeezing in an extra shirt or two, soft side luggage takes the cake. The external pockets of soft side luggage facilitate better organization, whereas hard-sided ones usually have a uniform interior with limited external access.
Importance in Travel
Soft side carry-ons are a favorite among travelers who value packing convenience and flexibility. They shine in scenarios where adaptability with packing space is key, such as on return trips laden with souvenirs. These bags are also lightweight, helping you adhere to strict airline weight limits. Their maneuverability and functional features like front pockets can make your airport experience far smoother. Overall, if versatility and lightweight maneuverability are your priorities, this type of luggage might be your best bet.
Brands and Models Tested
Swiss Gear Sion
The Swiss Gear Sion is a no-frills, budget-friendly option ideal for those who don’t travel frequently. It’s known for its scuff-resistant polyester exterior, which provides durability for casual trips. However, it lacks in the wheel department, as some users report less-than-smooth rolling experiences.
London Fog Newcastle
London Fog’s Newcastle model stands out for its unique aesthetics, boasting a woven herringbone material. Unfortunately, the style does not compensate for its lower durability, and some users have expressed concerns over its long-term integrity and susceptibility to stains.
Delsey Paris Helium DLX
Renowned for its lightweight construction, the Delsey Paris Helium DLX offers durability without the weight. Its design includes anti-theft zippers and ample organizational options, making it a functional favorite among those who value security alongside convenience.
Samsonite Ascentra
The Samsonite Ascentra shines with its use of sustainable materials. Made from recycled polyester, it demonstrates environmental awareness without sacrificing functionality. This bag also includes a handy USB port, making it easy to charge your devices on the go.
TravelPro Platinum Elite
TravelPro’s Platinum Elite is often revered for its organizational prowess. Featuring multiple compartments and genuine leather handles, this model is both stylish and efficient, the ideal choice for frequent travelers who need to stay organized.
Briggs & Riley ZDX International
Briggs & Riley ZDX International sets itself apart with an impressive lifetime guarantee. It’s built to last, with high-quality materials that withstand the rigors of frequent travel. For those who put durability above all else, this option might be the perfect match.
Hartmann Ratio Classic
The Hartmann Ratio Classic exudes luxury, with a refined look that appeals to style-conscious travelers. Despite its elegance, it’s heavier than others on this list, which might be a drawback if you’re looking to keep your luggage weight down.
TUMI Alpha 3 International
The TUMI Alpha 3 is synonymous with premium durability. Constructed to endure extensive use, it’s perfect for those who are frequently in the air and demand a tough, reliable companion for their travels.
Key Features Evaluated
Dimensions and Weight
Every carry-on tested adheres to the standard dimensions of 22” x 14” x 9”, fitting comfortably within most airline overhead compartments. Weights differ among the models, from the lightweight Delsey at 3 kg to the heavier TUMI at 4.9 kg, reflecting a balance between material strength and ease of carriage.
Wheels and Mobility
Mobility is crucial, featuring four 360-degree spinner wheels for each model. However, wheel quality varies, impacting the ease with which you can navigate crowded airports. We found that smoother, self-aligning wheels, like those on the TravelPro, significantly enhance travel convenience.
Handles and Usability
Handles underwent scrutiny concerning their comfort and durability. Models like the TravelPro, with leather handles, offer a premium feel and strength. Yet, some models, such as London Fog, presented handle design concerns, particularly in their unorthodox positioning.
Durability and Materials
Durability is tied to material quality. Brands like Samsonite and Briggs & Riley promote recycled and robust materials, ensuring longevity. Conversely, bags like the London Fog, despite their visual appeal, might not hold up under rigorous travel conditions.
Testing Methodology
Testing Process Overview
We conducted a thorough, hands-on evaluation of each model. Our process included real-world tests such as navigating through terminals, lifting into overhead bins, and assessing packing efficiency.
Criteria for Evaluation
The criteria utilized involved dimensions, weight, wheel smoothness, handle comfort, durability, and value for money. This comprehensive evaluation aimed to unveil each bag’s strengths and weaknesses.
Conditions Under Which Testing Was Conducted
Testing occurred in typical travel environments including airports and public transportation, imitating common travel scenarios. This helped ensure feedback was reflective of user experiences.
Performance Results and Comparisons
Mobility and Ease of Use
The TravelPro emerged as the leader due to its excellent wheel technology and intuitive design. While Swiss Gear offered good value, its wheel performance left much to be desired.
Durability Testing Results
Briggs & Riley essentially epitomized durability, thanks to its robust materials and lifetime guarantees. TUMI and Samsonite were also found durable, suitable for regular travelers.
Usability and Convenience
The organizational features in the TravelPro and Samsonite models made them stand out. Their pocket designs and charging options catered well to modern traveler needs.
Price Versus Value
Samsonite Ascentra presents exceptional value under $200, with sustainable materials and durability. Meanwhile, TravelPro, though pricier, justifies its cost with superior design features.
Pros and Cons of Each Brand
Affordability and Quality of Swiss Gear
Swiss Gear, while affordable, mirrors basic functionality, which might not satisfy frequent travelers seeking durability and comfort.
Luxury Aesthetics of London Fog
With London Fog, aesthetics take precedence, however, at the sacrifice of longevity and practical usability.
Lightweight Features of Delsey Paris
Delsey Paris stands out for maintaining a sturdy yet lightweight design, an asset for those aiming to maximize their carry capacity.
Sustainable Materials of Samsonite
Samsonite’s sustainable approach aligns with travelers seeking eco-friendly choices, complemented by robust build quality.
Organizational Benefits of TravelPro
TravelPro leads in offering extensive organizational solutions, making packing straightforward and efficient.
Lifetime Guarantee of Briggs & Riley
Offering a lifetime guarantee, Briggs & Riley provides peace of mind through a commitment to repair and service that justifies its higher price.
Luxurious Design of Hartmann
Hartmann attracts with its sophisticated look, though this comes with increased weight and a higher price.
Premium Durability of Tumi
TUMI’s focus on premium durability makes it an ideal choice for those who find themselves traveling often and require reliable gear.
Recommendations Based on Price and Quality
Best Value Under $200: Samsonite
The Samsonite Ascentra balances sustainability, features, and affordability, representing the best choice in the sub-$200 segment.
Overall Best Choice: TravelPro
For those who prioritize organization and reliability, TravelPro’s Platinum Elite emerges as the best overall selection.
Runners-up: Delsey Paris and Briggs & Riley
Both Delsey Paris, for lightweight features, and Briggs & Riley, for unmatched durability, serve as worthy considerations.
Additional Travel Resources and Tips
Packing Lists and Essentials
Create a list before you travel, focusing on essentials like toiletries, chargers, and travel documents to avoid last-minute rushes.
Suggested Travel Gadgets
Consider gadgets such as portable chargers, noise-canceling headphones, and universal adapters to enhance your travel experience.
Credit Card Recommendations
Look for travel credit cards offering rewards like miles or no foreign transaction fees, as these can save money and offer travel benefits.
Long-term Packing Advice
For extended trips, think versatile clothing, which you can layer, and remember to pack fabrics that wash easily to manage weight and space.
Finding Cheap Flights
Utilize flight comparison tools, be flexible with dates, and consider flying mid-week, as these strategies can yield considerable savings.
Considerations for Choosing Carry-On Luggage
Airline Dimension Requirements
Ensure your carry-on complies with airline-specific dimensions, which can vary and affect whether your bag flies free or incurs charges.
Personal Travel Needs
Reflect on your needs—do you need organization, durability, or simply affordably? Let this guide your choice.
Price and Longevity
While budget is important, often investing a bit more leads to a product that lasts longer and provides better service.
Aesthetic Preferences
While functionality should be a priority, choosing a design that resonates with your style can complement your travel experience.
Conclusion
Final Thoughts on the Best Carry-On Options
From budget buys to luxury picks, each bag brings distinct benefits. Assessing needs against what’s available will help steer your choice.
Long-term Value and Durability
Investing in quality often leads to long-term savings. Brands like Briggs & Riley, with their lifetime guarantees, offer enduring value.
Suggestions for Future Travel
With technology advancing and more sustainable options emerging, staying updated will ensure your travel gear complements modern needs.